So, when I think of Classic Custard Pie, honestly, I picture my grandmother’s rickety kitchen table—she had this orange teapot with a chipped lid (which I wasn’t allowed to touch, naturally), and every now and then, she’d let me lick the pie filling bowl before she slid the pan into that ancient oven. I still don’t quite know how her pies always turned out so dreamy, and even now, there are days mine go a bit, let’s say, interesting in the middle. But that’s half the fun, right?
Why You’ll Love This (Or At Least Why I Do)
I make this pie whenever I’ve got that nagging sweet tooth but seriously can’t be bothered with anything fussy (I mean, hello, no double crust to wrestle with). My family goes mad for it—my nephew once tried to take a whole slice with his bare hands and lost half of it down his shirt, but did he care? Not a jot. Oh, and the smell, let me tell you. If happiness had a scent, it’d be fresh custard bubbling away in the oven, maybe with a dash of nutmeg on top.
The only catch? Waiting for it to cool. Has anyone really waited the full amount of time? Not in this house! Sometimes, if I’m feeling proper lazy, I’ll just use a store-bought crust (and not feel even a tickle of guilt). The real beauty is, it’s never exactly the same twice, but it’s always devoured before I can blink.
What You’ll Need (And A Few Alternatives)
- 1 unbaked pie crust (Sometimes I use that ready-rolled stuff from the shop, but once in a blue moon I’ll make my own. Gram used to swear by the kind with lard, but I’m semi-vegetarian now, so… you see).
- 3 large eggs (Fresh is nice, but I have made it with two and a yolk when I accidentally dropped one. Still worked!)
- 3/4 cup white sugar (Brown sugar in a pinch! Gives it a caramelly thing.)
- 1/4 tsp salt
- 2 cups whole milk (I tried coconut milk once and um, probably wouldn’t again unless you like pie that’s, let’s say, adventurous.)
- 1 tsp vanilla extract (Honestly, store-brand is fine.)
- Nutmeg, for dusting (Cinnamon works if you’re out, or nothing at all. One time I tried cocoa powder. Mistake!)
How I Actually Make It (With Side Comments)
- Preheat your oven to 350°F (about 180°C). If you forget and try to heat it last minute, I’ve done that too—just stick the pie in anyway. It all works out, just takes longer.
- Roll out your pie crust and press it, not too fancy, into a 9-inch pie tin. If it tears, patch it up and pretend like that’s what you meant to do. No one’s the wiser.
- In a bowl, whisk eggs, sugar, and salt together until they blend up all nice. This is where I usually start daydreaming, so don’t overbeat it to death; just get it smooth-ish.
- Heat the milk in a small saucepan, just until it’s kind of hot but definitely not boiling. Scalded milk scares me a bit (I’ve overflowed it more times than I should admit), so I hover with a wooden spoon.
- Pour the warm milk, slow as you like, into your egg mixture, whisking steadily. If you’re clumsy (like me), do it over the sink to catch drips. Don’t freak out if it looks a bit frothy—that settles down later.
- Stir in the vanilla. On second thought, sometimes I add a splash extra, just because. Pour the whole custardy business into your crust.
- Dust with loads of grated nutmeg. Or a little. Just don’t skip it; it feels wrong without that spicy whiff.
- Bake for about 40 to 50 minutes. Check at 40—a butter knife poked into the center should (kinda) come out clean. It’ll jiggle like jelly; that’s normal. Don’t panic if it puffs up a bit, it’ll settle down as it cools.
- Let it cool. Not to sound bossy, but your tongue will regret it if you slice too soon. Learned that the hard way (several times).
Things I Wish I Knew Earlier
- Covering the crust edges with foil makes the whole over-browning thing go away. No more burnt-siding fiascos.
- If it jiggles too much and seems soupy after baking, pop it back in for another five or ten. Don’t sweat the small stuff!
- Actually, letting it sit overnight in the fridge? Game-changer. Tastes better next day (unless someone nicks a slice at midnight).
Twists I’ve Tried (For Better or Worse)
- Lemon zest in the custard? Surprisingly fresh. Maybe not traditional, but cheerful.
- Once mixed in some bourbon. Adults only! Lovely if you like a tipple.
- Pumpkin puree attempt—nope, just make pumpkin pie if you want pumpkin pie. Lesson learned.
What If I Don’t Have Every Tool?
No pie plate? I’ve cobbled this together in a cake tin and once in a lasagna dish. Not fancy, but it works. No whisk? Use a fork and some elbow grease.
Keeping It Fresh (Sort Of)
Store in the fridge, covered. It claims it’ll last 3 days, but in my house, pie never sees day two. One time, I tried freezing a slice—wasn’t the same, but not a disaster either, just a bit watery when thawed.
How I Like To Serve It
I’ll go for a dollop of whipped cream if I’ve got it, but honestly, most times it’s just me, a fork, and maybe a mug of builder’s tea. My niece likes it with berries on top (posh!). Sometimes we’ll eat it for breakfast—don’t tell my neighbor, she’s the sensible type.
Things I Learned The Hard Way
- Don’t skip preheating the oven. I did once, tried to save time; big mistake. Pie was raw in the middle, burnt on the bottom.
- You want the custard a bit jiggly—not firm like a brick. Overbaking isn’t worth it (you end up with eggy rubber!).
- Let it cool on a rack, not just the stovetop, or you get that sweaty bottom (pie, not person—though honestly, both happen in my kitchen).
oh right, FAQ (Because People Actually Ask)
Can I use skim milk instead of whole? Well, yes, but why? It’s thinner, so the set isn’t as creamy. If that’s what you’ve got, go for it, just don’t blame me if it’s a bit wobbly at first.
Is this safe for kids (with all those eggs)? Yep, it bakes long enough to cook the eggs properly. My 4-year-old niece is living proof.
Help! My pie cracked—what’d I do? Sounds like it was overbaked or cooled too quick. But hey, a bit of whipped cream hides anything.
Can I double the recipe? I suppose, but make two pies, not one giant one or you’ll have a mess on your hands (and probably your oven floor, yikes!)
What if I want it less sweet? Cut the sugar by a couple of spoonfuls; that’s usually enough.
Oh, and if you’re ever out of vanilla, try almond extract, but maybe don’t tell any purists you’ve done it.
Ingredients
- 1 unbaked 9-inch pie crust
- 3 large eggs
- 3/4 cup granulated sugar
- 2 cups whole milk
- 1 teaspoon pure vanilla extract
- 1/4 teaspoon salt
- 1/4 teaspoon ground nutmeg
- 1 tablespoon unsalted butter (melted, optional)
Instructions
-
1Preheat the oven to 350°F (175°C). Place the pie crust into a 9-inch pie plate and crimp the edges.
-
2In a medium bowl, whisk together eggs, sugar, and salt until well combined.
-
3Gradually whisk in milk, vanilla extract, and melted butter until the mixture is smooth.
-
4Pour the custard mixture into the prepared pie crust and sprinkle the top with ground nutmeg.
-
5Bake for 45 to 50 minutes or until the center is just set and a knife inserted near the center comes out clean.
-
6Allow the pie to cool completely on a wire rack before slicing and serving.
CLICK FOR NUTRITION INFO
↑
Approximate Information for One Serving
Serving Size:
1 serving
Calories:
240cal
Protein:
6 gg
Fat:
10 gg
Saturated Fat:
0g
Trans Fat:
0g
Cholesterol:
0mg
Sodium:
0mg
Potassium:
0mg
Total Carbs:
30 gg
Fiber:
0g
Sugar:
0g
Net Carbs:
0g
Vitamin A:
0
Vitamin C:
0mg
Calcium:
0mg
Iron:
0mg
Nutrition Disclaimers
Number of total servings shown is approximate. Actual number of servings will depend on your preferred portion sizes.
Nutritional values shown are general guidelines and reflect information for 1 serving using the ingredients listed, not including any optional ingredients. Actual macros may vary slightly depending on specific brands and types of ingredients used.
To determine the weight of one serving, prepare the recipe as instructed. Weigh the finished recipe, then divide the weight of the finished recipe (not including the weight of the container the food is in) by the desired number of servings. Result will be the weight of one serving.
Did you make this recipe?
Please consider Pinning it!!
